The World Without Us

By Alan Weisman

20 Readers

Stuart

Stephen

thekeeneye

Brad

Ronnie

Vanessa

tsutton

davy

Veronika

willpowers

Paul

Stephen

Ole

Amar

Marri


Marri Lynn read 4 pages in The World Without Us

21

Comment ·

Marri Lynn The World Without Us

"Rain and snow mysteriously, inexorably work their way under sills."

I've seen personification less irritating than this in a 6th grade poetry workshop.

Comment ·

Marri Lynn The World Without Us

Already this far in, I'm noticing some trends in Weisman's narrative I feared I'd encounter.

Whether or not it was intended, the Zapara and the "rubber genocide" were romanticized right off the bat. A predictable, poor appeal to emotion, in my opinion. I also really hoped I wouldn't see the words "nature" and "revenge" on the same page, let alone in the same sentence.

Nevertheless, reading on, because the subject is fascinating. I hope Weisman will stick closer to his illustrative and intriguing case-examples and narrativize a little less as the book goes on.

The book's issues and possibilities, simply stated, speak for themselves.

Comment ·

Remember: this book was written for a popular audience, he wanted the everyman to read it, as it should be. Unfortunately, a popular audience tends to like things like this (Twilight? Thank god trees aren't Adonis-like). Also, the the book is this way to get the reader "into" the subject matter, particularly in the first half. I agree it is irritating in the initial part of the book, but just try to ignore it and don't get into how it is written, because like you said, the issues are what should be attended to, not the style, and I strongly think this is a book everyone should read. As you get further into the book, the pace quickens, and things get darker, more irreparable and hopeless. The thesis, if not the title, of this book should really be "We're fucked: stop procreating and kill yourself now." The chapters really WORTH reading are everything from plastics onwards. The beginning is preaching the power of nature to overcome and overtake everything we have done, and yeah it's romanticized but interesting nonetheless, but then the second half is all "Oh, just kidding! We have actually done too much damage to even consider repairing." Weisman really butters you up with the "Good News" first, which in my opinion is strategic considering the majority of the audience wouldn't read on if it started with the worst because nobody wants to be told we're all screwed.

5y

Marri Lynn read 4 pages in The World Without Us

17

Comment ·

Marri Lynn read 13 pages in The World Without Us

13

Comment ·

Jakob Wells finished reading The World Without Us

7345

Comment ·

Jakob Wells read 1629 locations in The World Without Us

1629

Comment ·

Chris Drackett read 56 pages in The World Without Us

56

Comment ·

jane hidell read 29 pages in The World Without Us

29

Comment ·

jane hidell read 12 pages in The World Without Us

41

Comment ·

Prev Next